Autistic teacher awarded £850,000 in discrimination claim

In the case of Mr MW v The Governing Body of Cardinal Newman Catholic School Mr MW, an autistic teacher, was awarded £850,000 in compensation after being unfairly dismissed from his role as head of maths at Cardinal Newman Catholic School in Brighton. Mr MW, diagnosed with autism in 2017, was known to become fixated on certain issues, leading to multiple complaints at work. Despite his love for teaching, his grievances were seen by the school’s leadership as taking up too much time, and after several disputes, Mr MW was eventually suspended. He was offered a settlement and later a demotion, both of which he reluctantly accepted under protest, leading to further tension with his bosses.

In the case of Mr MW v The Governing Body of Cardinal Newman Catholic School Mr MW, an autistic teacher, was awarded £850,000 in compensation after being unfairly dismissed from his role as head of maths at Cardinal Newman Catholic School in Brighton. Mr MW, diagnosed with autism in 2017, was known to become fixated on certain issues, leading to multiple complaints at work. Despite his love for teaching, his grievances were seen by the school’s leadership as taking up too much time, and after several disputes, Mr MW was eventually suspended. He was offered a settlement and later a demotion, both of which he reluctantly accepted under protest, leading to further tension with his bosses.

Mr MW’s troubles with the school began in 2015 when he supported a colleague in a tribunal case. Shortly after, Mr MW found himself the target of what he believed were deliberate efforts to undermine him. He raised grievances about perceived bullying and felt that his involvement in the previous tribunal played a role in how he was treated. Despite his complaints, the school did not initially uphold them, and tensions escalated. In 2017, around the time of his autism diagnosis, Mr MW met with the chair of governors as the headteacher claimed he could no longer work with him.

The school’s leadership grew increasingly frustrated with Mr MW, citing his constant grievances and subject access requests as distractions from the broader needs of the school. They offered a financial settlement to end the working relationship, but Mr MW refused, leading to his suspension while the school investigated the breakdown of relationships. During this period, Mr MW expressed that despite his complaints, he was committed to the truth and loved his job. He acknowledged that his autism contributed to his fixation on certain issues and his persistence in pursuing them.

In 2018, after another grievance, the school implemented recommendations from the National Autistic Society to help Mr MW return to work. However, the new role offered to him—a “Head

Performance Coach”—was seen by Mr MW as a demotion, sparking further grievances. Although he agreed to take the position under protest, the conditions of his return frustrated the school, and he was ultimately dismissed. Mr MW sued for unfair dismissal, victimization, and disability discrimination, all of which were upheld by the tribunal.

The tribunal found that the school failed to account for Mr MW’s autism in their decision-making process, particularly how his behaviour was impacted by the condition. Judge Antony Hyams-Parish ruled that Mr MW’s dismissal was unfair and disproportionate, awarding him £850,000 for loss of earnings, injury to feelings, and pension loss. The school has until September 27 to make the payment.

    Read more

    Latest News

    Read More

    The evolving leadership persona

    6 December 2024

    Newsletter

    Receive the latest HR news and strategic content

    Please note, as per the GDPR Legislation, we need to ensure you are ‘Opted In’ to receive updates from ‘theHRDIRECTOR’. We will NEVER sell, rent, share or give away your data to third parties. We only use it to send information about our products and updates within the HR space To see our Privacy Policy – click here

    Latest HR Jobs

    University of Glasgow – Estates DirectorateSalary: £40,247 to £45,163 per annum. UofG Grade 7 This provides summary information and comment on the subject areas covered.

    HR M&A Expertise: Extensive experience having led 10+ mergers and acquisitions within or for a global organization, focusing on HR due diligence and integration planning.

    Job Details: HR Director – Mergers & Acquisitions. Join Sage as our Director of HR – Mergers & Acquisitions, a high-visibility role where you’ll lead

    Join Sage as our Director of HR – Mergers & Acquisitions, a high-visibility role where you’ll lead M&A efforts for the People Function—from due diligence

    Read the latest digital issue of theHRDIRECTOR for FREE

    Read the latest digital issue of theHRDIRECTOR for FREE