EAT rules that autistic insurance claims advisor was not dismissed but employment was terminated consensually

In the recent case of Riley v Direct Line Insurance Group plc, the Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed Mr Riley’s appeal against the decision of the employment tribunal to reject his unfair dismissal claim against his employer, on the basis that there was in fact no dismissal but rather a consensual termination to his employment

In the recent case of Riley v Direct Line Insurance Group plc, the Employment Appeal Tribunal dismissed Mr Riley’s appeal against the decision of the employment tribunal to reject his unfair dismissal claim against his employer, on the basis that there was in fact no dismissal but rather a consensual termination to his employment.

The Appellant was disabled by reason of autism spectrum disorder, anxiety and depression and was employed by Direct Line Insurance Group as a Home’s Claims Advisor from March 2012. From 2014 until October 2017 Mr Riley was absent from work with anxiety and depression. For much of this period, he was paid 80% of his normal salary under a private health insurance scheme.

Following an assessment in August 2017, Mr Riley returned to work but was signed off by his GP again in May 2018 for ongoing anxiety and paranoia. In August 2018 Direct Line obtained a medical report which confirmed that it would be difficult to see Mr Riley sufficiently perform his role in the near or medium future.

Therefore, Direct Line called a meeting with Mr Riley to discuss the potential termination of his employment, with the insurers still paying him 80% of his normal salary despite no longer being employed by Direct Line. Mr Riley was happy with the proposal and his only query was whether payments would be made up to his retirement age. It was agreed that HR would investigate this and later confirmed that the payments would indeed be made until the state pension age.

Mr Riley went on to proactively pursue the option of this scheme and agreed to the termination of his employment because he wanted to take advantage of it as it was confirmed that payments would continue until state pension age.

Mr Riley then brought proceedings for unfair dismissal and disability discrimination against Direct Line.

In the first instance, the employment tribunal found that the termination was not a dismissal because it was consensual between the parties and therefore it could not amount to an unfair dismissal.

On appeal, the employment appeal tribunal also found that:

  • that the ET had not failed to make reasonable adjustments in the way he was cross-examined and there had been no substantive unfairness in the hearing;
  • that the ET had properly decided not to extend the time for the reasonable adjustments claims in view of his subsequent decision to agree to the termination of his employment rather than seeking to return to work.

Read more

Latest News

Read More

The evolving leadership persona

6 December 2024

Newsletter

Receive the latest HR news and strategic content

Please note, as per the GDPR Legislation, we need to ensure you are ‘Opted In’ to receive updates from ‘theHRDIRECTOR’. We will NEVER sell, rent, share or give away your data to third parties. We only use it to send information about our products and updates within the HR space To see our Privacy Policy – click here

Latest HR Jobs

University of Glasgow – Estates DirectorateSalary: £40,247 to £45,163 per annum. UofG Grade 7 This provides summary information and comment on the subject areas covered.

Join Sage as our Director of HR – Mergers & Acquisitions, a high-visibility role where you’ll lead M&A efforts for the People Function—from due diligence

HR Director – Mergers & Acquisitions Join Sage as our Director of HR – Mergers & Acquisitions, a high-visibility role where you’ll lead M&A efforts

University of Oxford – Department of International DevelopmentSalary: £31,459 to £36,616 per annum. Grade 5 This provides summary information and comment on the subject areas

Read the latest digital issue of theHRDIRECTOR for FREE

Read the latest digital issue of theHRDIRECTOR for FREE