People hire for acceptability not capability

People hire for acceptability not capability

Cognitive neuroscientist and ageing specialist Dr Lynda Shaw argues we are facing an ageism epidemic in the workplace with employers more swayed by age than an employee’s calibre and potential to perform exceptionally in a role.

Dr Lynda Shaw argues: “Inequality of the sexes has been on the agenda for years, but I think it is now vital to look at the huge issues we have with ageism as well. When managers are looking to recruit new employees nowadays they are often more concerned about what is thought of them by hiring an older person, than considering the capabilities of the older applicant. This is a trend that I see more and more when speaking with managers. Highly regarded men and women are displaying total disregard for potential employees nearing retirement age.

“A strong set of skills, expertise and loyalty are being overlooked and lost to industry because of old behavioural conditioning. Isn’t it better to trust our judgment and think only about the job spec and the applicant? Perhaps focusing on the fit of someone in terms of contribution is all that is needed.” There is, however, an exception to this trend. Dr Shaw believes managers seem able to hold their head high if they are seen to hire older people as interims just to exploit them for their contact list within their business network. She says: “This information has a ‘shelf life’ as contacts move on. This means that there is a bit of a lather to hire an older person when they are recently out on the job market, but only as an interim. This may result in a quick fix for employer and employee, but there is no thought of what else they can bring to the table. It is also a terrible waste of talent.”

“If we continue to treat people like this, they will lose interest and either retire, start a business of their own or change course completely. This is dangerous for industry. We are just beginning to witness a massive brain drain as the ‘baby boomers’ start heading to retirement. High unemployment figures and students fighting for work have given us the illusion that there is plenty of talent out there. This is both short-sighted and misleading. Take university fees, for instance. Here in the UK they are now very expensive and our young people are being seduced to foreign soil with the promise of less debt and a more attractive CV because of the enriching experience of learning in a different country. What is the chance of them coming back? We are at risk of losing talent at both ends of the scale, both older and younger people.”

Dr Lynda Shaw believes it is urgent that we engage every age group in order to have strong work forces to ensure growth and development. Part of this means hiring older people for their capabilities and ignoring spurious discriminatory thoughts. “Considering the opinions of others is of course an important factor to consider in any decision making process, it suggests a good level of emotional intelligence. Employing someone substandard simply because they fit the companies’ youthful demographic will only cost businesses more money in time and training in the long run.

Read more

Latest News

Read More

Conflict Intelligence: A Defining Skill for Emerging Leaders

18 August 2025

Culture

18 August 2025

This article delves into the core reasons why these "teams within teams" emerge. It provides leaders with eight psychologically grounded strategies to realign loyalties and...

Career Development

15 August 2025

The self-awareness you gain as a caregiver, the resilience you build through sleepless nights, the ability to stay present during a meltdown (theirs or yours!)...

Newsletter

Receive the latest HR news and strategic content

Please note, as per the GDPR Legislation, we need to ensure you are ‘Opted In’ to receive updates from ‘theHRDIRECTOR’. We will NEVER sell, rent, share or give away your data to third parties. We only use it to send information about our products and updates within the HR space To see our Privacy Policy – click here

Latest HR Jobs

Job Purpose We are seeking a proactive and people-focused HR & People Manager to lead all aspects of human resources. This key leadership role is

Job Purpose We are seeking a proactive and people-focused HR & People Manager to lead all aspects of human resources. This key leadership role is

Act as the local subject matter expert on HRpensation matters, and partner with HR colleagues in providing modelling, guidance and advice onpensation structures across multiple

We are seeking to hire an enthusiastic, passionate and experienced Assistant Director of People and Culture who has hands on experience supporting an HR function

Read the latest digital issue of theHRDIRECTOR for FREE

Read the latest digital issue of theHRDIRECTOR for FREE