Care assistant wins unfair dismissal claim after being charged with murder

In the case of J D v Care UK Community Partnerships Ltd the Claimant began her employment with Care UK Community Partnerships Ltd (“The Respondent”) on 2 October 2019 as a care assistant, providing personal care to vulnerable residents at Cairdean Nursing Home.

In the case of J D v Care UK Community Partnerships Ltd the Claimant began her employment with Care UK Community Partnerships Ltd (“The Respondent”) on 2 October 2019 as a care assistant, providing personal care to vulnerable residents at Cairdean Nursing Home.

On 18 October 2022, the claimant was arrested and charged with murder. While she remained in police custody for 30 hours, her daughter informed her employer that her absence was due to COVID-19.

The following day, the claimant appeared in court and was subsequently released on bail. The incident was reported in the Daily Record newspaper, which mentioned her name, age, and hometown but did not disclose her employer’s identity.

On 20 October 2022, the claimant’s daughter informed the home manager that her mother had been arrested and charged with murder. As a result, the claimant was suspended with full pay pending an investigation. The respondent cited concerns about “a breakdown in trust and confidence and potentially bringing the company into disrepute.”

A fact-finding meeting was held seven days later, during which the claimant explained her situation. She admitted that her absence was not due to COVID-19 but because she had been in police custody. She maintained her innocence and expressed hope that the situation would be resolved.

On 31 October 2022, the respondent’s investigator submitted a report concluding that the claimant’s dishonesty regarding her absence and arrest had caused a breakdown in trust. Consequently, the claimant was invited to a disciplinary hearing on 14 November 2022. Accompanied by her union representative, she reiterated her previous statements. However, the respondent emphasised the breakdown in trust and the potential reputational damage to the company. As a result, the claimant was dismissed with payment in lieu of notice.

In the years that followed, the claimant struggled with her mental health and was prescribed medication. She began ACAS early conciliation in early 2023 and initiated employment tribunal proceedings on 14 April 2023.

On 21 March 2024, she was acquitted of the criminal charges but remained unfit to work.

The tribunal determined that the claimant’s dismissal was potentially fair due to the substantial reason of reputational damage. However, the tribunal found that the disciplinary procedure was unfair because the risk of reputational damage and alternatives to dismissal were not adequately discussed.

Therefore, the unfair dismissal claim was successful, but the tribunal concluded that a proper discussion would have likely resulted in her dismissal due to the significant reputational risk and cost implications of indefinite suspension. Consequently, they deemed it just and equitable to reduce the compensatory award to nil.

    Read more

    Latest News

    Read More

    The evolving leadership persona

    6 December 2024

    Newsletter

    Receive the latest HR news and strategic content

    Please note, as per the GDPR Legislation, we need to ensure you are ‘Opted In’ to receive updates from ‘theHRDIRECTOR’. We will NEVER sell, rent, share or give away your data to third parties. We only use it to send information about our products and updates within the HR space To see our Privacy Policy – click here

    Latest HR Jobs

    University of Glasgow – Estates DirectorateSalary: £40,247 to £45,163 per annum. UofG Grade 7 This provides summary information and comment on the subject areas covered.

    HR M&A Expertise: Extensive experience having led 10+ mergers and acquisitions within or for a global organization, focusing on HR due diligence and integration planning.

    Job Details: HR Director – Mergers & Acquisitions. Join Sage as our Director of HR – Mergers & Acquisitions, a high-visibility role where you’ll lead

    Join Sage as our Director of HR – Mergers & Acquisitions, a high-visibility role where you’ll lead M&A efforts for the People Function—from due diligence

    Read the latest digital issue of theHRDIRECTOR for FREE

    Read the latest digital issue of theHRDIRECTOR for FREE